Internet Architecture Board

RFC2850

The IAB’s response to ICANN’s solicitation on DNS stability, 7 March 2008

Home»Documents»IAB Correspondence, Reports, and Selected Documents»2008»The IAB's response to ICANN's solicitation on DNS stability, 7 March 2008
To: new-gtlds-dns-stability@icann.org From: Danny McPherson <danny@tcb.net>
Subject: Input on new gTLDs & stability Date: Fri, 7 Mar 2008 07:43:51 -0700 Cc: IAB <iab@iab.org>

This message is in response to your solicitation for public comment on DNS Stability: The Effect of New gTLDs on the Internet Domain Name System, provided here:

http://www.icann.org/announcements/announcement-06feb08.htm

The IAB, in reviewing these materials has one concern beyond those already provided by the GNSO. The one concern is that in a number of environments the use of certain domain suffixes (e.g., .local) is common. Although the use of these suffixes is not standardized, nor are these suffixes registered in any manner, the introduction of such suffixes could lead to instability.

We also observe that while a terse reference to RFC 2606 is provided in the Glossary section of the ICANN GNSO “Final Report on Introduction of New Generic Top-Level Domains”, the reserved names themselves are not all included in the document, nor are they included in the “DNS Stability: The Effect of New Generic Top Level Domains on the Internet Domain Name System” document itself.

We would recommend that an appropriate technical ICANN committee (RSAC, RSTEP or SSAC) would assess, for each new gTLD proposed, if said gTLD would cause technical problems.

Danny McPherson
/on behalf of the IAB